Farm workplace tested by a side deal on unionizing By Bryan Little
We now know the broad strokes of California agriculture labor relations law going forward: unreliable majority-sup- port petitions for unions to demonstrate putative majority employee backing for union representation. AB 2183 also harbors another problem- atic provision that has been little discussed. For the first time, the ALRB will have au- thority to levy penalties up to $25,000 for unfair labor practices that previously war- ranted only remedial remedies such as back-pay. The highest penalty amounts will be reserved for unfair labor practices the board deems discriminatory or retaliatory. The new appeal bond requires an em- ployer to post a bond equivalent to the financial value of an ALRB’s order, includ- ing the new unfair labor practice penalties and back pay. The Legislature, many years ago, granted authority to ALRB to impose a collective bargaining agreement on an employer under certain circumstances. The costs of a three-year collective bar- gaining agreement imposed by the ALRB could be enormous, as could unfair labor practice penalties that could be assessed on an employee-by-employee basis. Employers would be required to post this appeal bond to be permitted to appeal the decisions of the quasi-judicial process at the ALRB. The Farm Employers Labor Service, which can be reached at 800-753-9073 or info@fels.net, can provide agricultural employers and supervisors resources and training on the ins and outs of card-check organizing. We can explain how to avoid common compliance problems that can encourage unnecessary unionization. (Bryan Little is director of employment policy for California Farm Bureau and chief operating officer of Farm Employers Labor Service (FELS). He may be contacted at blittle@cfbf.com.)
In late March, in a normally routine process to update the state budget to
conform to a law passed in a previ- ous legislative ses- sion, a California Assembly subcom- mittee approved a budget change pro- posal for Gov. Gavin Newsom’s 2023-24 state funding plan. This action marked
Bryan Little
a significant change in state policy on how labor relations in agriculture will be man- aged in the future. This action advanced a side deal between Newsom, the United Farm Workers and the California Labor Federation to ease unionization of agri- cultural workers, while eliminating re- quirements for secret-ballot elections for organizing. The governor initially signaled last year that he would not sign the mail-in ballot card-check legislation, Assembly Bill 2183. But then the governor and the labor groups agreed amongst themselves to amend the bill—and he reversed course and signed it into law. If the budget change proposal becomes law, it would amend and fortify card-check language in AB 2183 to aggressively pur- sue farm employees’ signatures on cards or petitions. As originally enacted, the bill provided for two paths for unions seeking to repre- sent agricultural employees. Under one, “labor peace” status, an employer may not express views against unionization and must allow organizers access to farm properties. Those who do not opt for labor peace are subject to unionization with the bill’s card check provisions.
Farm employees harvest cherries in San Joaquin County. Under a pending update to the state budget, farm employees may be subject to pressures to sign ballot cards or petitions from union organizers.
Guaranteed access by the California Agricultural Labor Relations Board was struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court as a violation of a farmer’s Fifth Amendment private property rights. Under labor peace, a union could claim majority status among employees of an ag- ricultural business with a mail-in ballot, with the ALRB providing and counting the ballots but unable to safeguard employees from union agent intimidation. In the time provided under AB 2183, no agricultural employer opted for labor peace status. Farm employers who opt out are still subject to unionization through card- check union organizing provisions. Long- standing national labor law allows em- ployers and unions to avail themselves of voluntary card-check. Employers could voluntarily recognize a union, and con- ceivably save on lawyers and consultants, if the union demonstrated majority support based on signed union authorization cards or petitions. This makes sense in an environment
where the employer sees benefit from a relationship with a union. Then again, this has seldom, if ever, been the case in California agriculture. Farm employees are likely to sign union cards just to get organizers to leave them alone. While UFW offers help with immigration issues and distributes some COVID, drought and flood relief funding, this provides opportunities to ask em- ployees to sign union cards or petitions. Up to a year later, the worker may find UFW using that signature to unionize an employer with whom they had no griev- ance whatsoever. In fact, he or she may not have known they would be working for the employer when signing the union organizer’s document. The budget change proposal stands to effectively make the agreement a rider to the 2023-24 state budget. No policy com- mittee will ever consider this change to state law. It’s certainly not the legislative process most of us learned about in our high school civics class.
VOL. 50, NO. 17
May 3, 2023
AG ALERT ® weekly newspaper is an official publication of the CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU
www.agalert.com www.cfbf.com
@cafarmbureau @cafarmbureau @cafarmbureau
@calfarmbureau
Board of Directors (District 1) Ronnie Leimgruber; (2) Scott Hudson; (3) Richard Miner; (4) Kevin Merrill; (5) Brian Medeiros; (6) Joey Airoso; (7) Donny Rollin; (8) April England; (9) Jay Mahil; (10) Jan Garrod; (11) Joe Martinez; (12) Paul Sanguinetti; (13) Ron Peterson; (14) Joe Fischer; (15) Clark Becker; (16) Garrett Driver; (17) Johnnie White; (18) Daniel Suenram; (19) Taylor Hagata; (20) Jim Morris; (21) Ronald Vevoda; (Young Farmers & Ranchers Committee Chair) Leah Groves. Advisory Members Al Stehly, Chair, CFB Rural Health Department, Glenda Humiston, University of California Cooperative Extension. Letters to the editor: Send to agalert@cfbf.com or Ag Alert, Attn: Editor, 2600 River Plaza Drive, Sacramento, CA 95833. Include name, address, phone number, email address; 250-word limit.
Melanie Duval- Chief Marketing Officer
ADVERTISING: Brock Tessandori- Business Development Manager (916) 561-5585 Shelby Baldridge- Advertising Operations Assistant Classifieds: (916) 561-5573 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento, CA 95833. Represented in the East and Midwest by J.L. Farmakis, Inc. Eastern office: Bill Farmakis 48 Topfield Rd., Wilton, CT 06897 (203) 834-8832; Fax: (203) 834-8825. Midwest office: Russ Parker , P.O. Box 7, Albia, IA 52531 (641) 946-7646, Bob Brunker , 8209 NW 81st Ct., Kansas City, MO 64152 (816) 746-8814, Jennifer Saylor , 8426 N. Winfield Ave., Kansas City, MO 64153 (816) 912-2804, Laura Rustmann , 901 Lands End Cir, St. Charles MO 63304, (636) 238-8548. AG ALERT (issn 0161-5408) is published weekly except weeks of Memorial Day, July 4, Thanksgiving,
Christmas; and with exceptions, by the California Farm Bureau, 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento CA 95833 (telephone: (916) 561-5570). Periodicals postage paid at Sacramento, California. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to AG ALERT, 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento, CA 95833. The California Farm Bureau does not assume responsibility for statements by advertisers or for products advertised in AG ALERT nor does the Federation assume responsibility for statements or expressions of opinion other than in editorials or in articles showing authorship by an officer, director, or employee of the California Farm Bureau Federation or its affiliates. No alcohol, tobacco or political ad-
Peter Hecht- Chief Editor, Publications
Christine Souza- Assistant Editor
Ching Lee- Assistant Editor
Caleb Hampton- Assistant Editor
Carolyn Sojak- Head Graphic Designer
Paula Erath- Graphic Designer
Nicole Pacheco- Graphic Designer
vertising will be accepted. Jamie Johansson , President
GENERAL INFORMATION: (916) 561-5570
Shannon Douglass , First Vice President Shaun Crook , Second Vice President
agalert@cfbf.com
Printed on Recycled Paper
BPA Business Publication Member
2 Ag Alert May 3, 2023
Powered by FlippingBook