Farmers and ranchers deserve a break on insurance
By Peter Ansel Far too many Californians have been im- pacted by a worsening insurance market crisis, which creates confusion and anxiety as it imposes ever higher costs in America’s most expensive state to live. The insurance
the State Fire Marshal to create new wild- fire mitigation area maps that change a current tiered fire-risk map delineation to better reflect overall “fire-hazard severity” in state and local responsibility areas. Farm Bureau’s amendments would re- quire the fire marshal to consider excluding areas such as working rangelands and cul- tivated, plowed and irrigated agricultural properties with a low risk of wildfire prop- agation when developing the new maps. The Department of Insurance plans to use the maps to identify distressed areas to track where insurers are competing for business and to move policies out of the FAIR Plan during the next two years. By rec- ognizing the low risks of agricultural prop- erties, many of those properties should move out of the FAIR Plan and back into the competitive insurance marketplace. The 2025-26 legislative session kicks off in just five months. While the past year largely saw the Legislature defer to Department of Insurance efforts to ad- dress the crisis, constituents are making daily calls to elected officials complain- ing about being nonrenewed by insurers. When those nonrenewals fail to account for actual property risks, consumers may rightly conclude the market is undertaking an exercise in expectancy confirmation, in which insurers will land the market exactly where they want it. Farmers and ranchers deserve fair treat- ment when the characteristics of working agricultural lands—with cleared proper- ties, low fuel loads and minimal wildfire risk—warrant a nonflammable classifica- tion in the state’s wildfire mitigation area mapping, as those same maps determine a consumer’s access to affordable insurance. (Peter Ansel is a senior policy advocate for the California Farm Bureau. He may be contacted at pansel@cfbf.com.)
crisis delays hous- ing production and impedes real estate transactions. It curbs discretionary spending, making it harder to raise local sales taxes. It
Peter Ansel
The 2021 Tennant Fire burns in the Klamath National Forest near Siskiyou County farmland. The California Farm Bureau works to ensure low-risk farm properties receive a nonflammable classification in state fire-hazard mapping used by insurers.
stresses retirees on fixed incomes, forcing many to consider resettling out of state. In 1988, California voters passed Proposition 103, which promised trans- parency and fairness in the rating plans process that determines the cost of insur- ance. The measure admirably kept insur- ance costs low, providing Californians with largely affordable property insurance rates. But in 2017, amid a then-record year for wildfire destruction in California, insurers faced massive property loss claims exceed- ing their ability to meet reasonable profit expectations and conduct business. The challenge deepened with new record fire years in 2018 and 2020. Meanwhile, the California Department of Insurance struggled to timely approve new rate plan filings due to issues includ- ing staffing levels and legal challenges. By the early 2020s, it was no surprise that in- surers were taking actions to create a new market dynamic to restore profitability to their California portfolios. It may be hard to describe nonrenewals or cancellations of residential and com- mercial property insurance policies as a strategy. But those are the levers insurers
have used to make their case to California that the state market is broken. The California Fair Access to Insurance Requirements, or FAIR Plan, the state’s insurer of last resort, has faced surging de- mands to provide insurance alternatives, which often come at high costs. This is be- cause residential and commercial proper- ty policyholders—including farmers and ranchers—have faced market cancella- tions or nonrenewals, even for properties outside high fire-risk areas. Insurers rely on satellite imagery and drone flyovers to identity reasons for non- renewing property insurance policies with- out providing consumers with photographs, video or even a report on how to mitigate those issues. Nonrenewal determinations could be based on insurers’ internal guide- lines, such as a 1-mile proximity to high-risk fire areas that fails to exempt structures sur- rounded by row crops or consider defensible space, proactive home hardening or other nonflammable aspects of those parcels. The Department of Insurance says it has an agreement with insurers on new
regulations to restore their ability to conduct business in our broken market. But nonrenewals are expected to increase during the next two years, with still more FAIR Plan policies being issued to address the fallout. The situation is unsustainable. Insurers will be allowed to submit rating plans based on new catastrophe modeling, which may bring higher rates to all poli- cyholders in the state. State Farm asked for a 30% rate increase in early July just to stay in the market, arguing that the in- crease would fend off insolvency issues. Obviously, insurers need to be able to pay incurred claims, which include high costs of rebuilding in California. Last year, the California Farm Bureau sponsored state Senate Bill 505 to help commercial insurance policies in the FAIR Plan participate in a clearinghouse program to move back to the competi- tive insurance marketplace. In July, Farm Bureau worked with Cal Fire and offices of Gov. Gavin Newsom and state Sen. Scott Weiner, D-San Francisco, to amend Senate Bill 610. The measure directs the Office of
VOL. 51, NO. 30
August 14, 2024
AG ALERT ® weekly newspaper is an official publication of the CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU • CFBF.COM
@cafarmbureau
@cafarmbureau
@cafarmbureau
@calfarmbureau
agalert.com
Board of Directors (District 1) Ronnie Leimgruber; (2) Scott Hudson; (3) Mark Lopez; (4) Kevin Merrill; (5) Kevin Robertson; (6) Joey Airoso; (7) Lorna Roush; (8) April England; (9) Jay Mahil; (10) Jan Garrod; (11) Joe Martinez; (12) Paul Sanguinetti; (13) Jake Wenger; (14) Joe Fischer; (15) Clark Becker; (16) Garrett Driver; (17) Johnnie White; (18) Daniel Suenram; (19) Taylor Hagata; (20) Jim Morris; (21) Ronald Vevoda; (Young Farmers & Ranchers Committee Chair) Trelawney Bullis. Advisory Members Jenny Holtermann, Chair, CFB Rural Health Department, Glenda Humiston, University of California Cooperative Extension. Letters to the editor: Send to agalert@cfbf.com or Ag Alert, Attn: Editor, 2600 River Plaza Drive, Sacramento, CA 95833. Include name, address, phone number, email address; 250-word limit.
Peter Hecht- Chief Editor, Publications
ADVERTISING: Brock Tessandori- Business Development Manager (916) 561-5585 Antonio Muniz- Sales Coordinator Classifieds: (916) 561-5570 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento, CA 95833. Represented in the East and Midwest by J.L. Farmakis, Inc. Eastern office: Bill Farmakis 48 Topfield Rd., Wilton, CT 06897 (203) 834-8832; Fax: (203) 834- 8825. Midwest office: Russ Parker, P.O. Box 7, Albia, IA 52531 (641) 946-7646, Bob Brunker, 8209 NW 81st Ct., Kansas City, MO 64152 (816) 746-8814, Jennifer Saylor, 8426 N. Winfield Ave., Kansas City, MO 64153 (816) 912-2804, Laura Rustmann, 901 Lands End Cir, St. Charles MO 63304, (636) 238-8548. AG ALERT (issn 0161-5408) is published weekly except weeks of Memorial Day, July 4, Thanksgiving,
Christmas; and with exceptions, by the California Farm Bureau, 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento CA 95833 (telephone: (916) 561-5570). Periodicals postage paid at Sacramento, California. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to AG ALERT, 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento, CA 95833. The California Farm Bureau does not assume responsibility for statements by advertisers or for products advertised in AG ALERT nor does the Federation assume responsibility for statements or expressions of opinion other than in editorials or in articles showing authorship by an officer, di- rector, or employee of the California Farm Bureau Federation or its affiliates. No alcohol, tobacco or political advertising will be accepted. Shannon Douglass, President Shaun Crook, First Vice President Ron Peterson, Second Vice President
Christine Souza- Assistant Editor
Ching Lee- Assistant Editor
Caleb Hampton- Assistant Editor
Shawn Collins- Production Designer
Paula Erath- Graphic Designer
GENERAL INFORMATION: (916) 561-5570
agalert@cfbf.com
Printed on Recycled Paper
BPA Business Publication Member
2 Ag Alert August 14, 2024
Powered by FlippingBook