Roadless Rule has kept forests from being managed By Shaun Crook
protection and recreation. Within this system, managers must navigate a rigid spec- trum of land-use rules that dictate exactly what activities are allowed on a given acre. This ranges from general forest zones where logging and grazing are permitted to strictly designated wilderness areas where motorized equipment is banned. Even most bicycles are prohibited. In the late 1990s, the Forest Service decided that the road system in our national forests was a major environ- mental and fiscal liability—a determination many of us in the forestry profession strongly dispute. By using that ra- tionale to pass the Roadless Rule, the federal government effectively created backdoor wilderness areas. It prohib- ited the active care and use of our public lands without undergoing the rigorous congressional process required to designate true wilderness. Access to our public lands remains one of the funda- mental tenets of being an American. Our forests have been supplying timber for the construction of this great nation for more than 250 years. From horses and trails to trains and log trucks, transportation systems have always been vital to the “use” of multiple-use lands. Today, this infrastructure is also key to our ability to battle fire, protect watersheds and create natural resource resiliency that is so important to our lives in California. While the environmental community has praised the Roadless Rule as being critical to the well-being of our na- tional forests, the numbers on the ground prove the exact contrary. The correlation between the implementation of the Roadless Rule and the catastrophic increase in acreage lost to wildfire in California and across the West is striking. From 2000 to 2011, nearly 10% of the forestland man- aged by the Forest Service was consumed by wildland fire. That number jumped to an astonishing 38% from 2012 to 2021. What this equates to is that fire has burned nearly 8 million acres of national forest in California during the past 25 years. Nearly half of our managed federal forest has burned since the application of this hands-off policy. With half our forest already lost to fire, we simply can- not afford to keep half of the remaining, unburned acres off-limits to proactive management. Roads and infra- structure have always been crucial for multiple use in our forests, and they will continue to be the primary tools for saving them. For too long, emotion has dictated the allowed activities on our national forests. It is past time for common sense, local expertise and active forestry to lead the way. Shaun Crook, who operates a family timber business in Tuolumne County, is first vice president of the California Farm Bureau. He can be reached at scrook@cfbf.com.
Inside Farm Bureau
The U.S. Forest Service has formally proposed rescind- ing the federal Roadless Area Conservation Rule, or Road- less Rule. As a California logger, I applaud this decision, as I believe it is an important step toward ending a rigid, one-size-fits-all approach and returning management decisions back to local forests. Social media has been abuzz with the announcement of this proposal. Some conservation groups are acting as if the sky is falling and that the last untouched areas are about to be paved over. This is simply not the case. If rescinded, active management, mechanical thinning, fuel reduction and all modern efforts to create fire resil- iency would once again be allowed on the 4 million acres of California land that have been off limits for a quarter of a century. Early in the Trump administration, Forest Service Chief Tom Schultz issued a directive to increase the pace and scale of logging and fuel reduction projects on all available lands. This order is meant to, as much as legally possible, streamline environmental review and other barriers to projects on national forests. Harvest levels and total treated acres on national for- estlands have declined or stagnated for nearly 30 years. However, the forest has kept growing, and there is more timber lost to death and disease—not including fire—than is harvested every year. To understand how we reached our current crisis—an unprecedented era of catastrophic, unmanaged wildfires that have scorched nearly 8 million acres of California’s na- tional forests during the past 25 years—it is worth exploring the origin of this bureaucratic barrier. Enacted during the Clinton administration, the Roadless Rule is an executive regulation that was never a law passed by Congress. It generally restricted road construction, com- mercial logging and active management activities across nearly 60 million acres of national forest nationwide. In California, more than 4 million acres, or about 20% of our national forestland, fall under what are known as in- ventoried roadless areas. These are lands situated outside of officially designated wilderness areas that would other- wise be open to multiple-use land management and fuel reduction activities. National forests in California with the most inventoried roadless areas are the Inyo, Los Padres, Sequoia, Shasta-Trinity and Klamath. Forestry and forest management are extremely import- ant to the success of California agriculture. Approximately 33% of the land in the state is forested, and about 60% of those acres sit on federal land. This is not just a matter of scenery; it is a matter of survival. Nearly 75% of our state’s
Shaun Crook First Vice President
water flows directly from our forests, and 60% of that crit- ical supply originates in the forests of the Sierra Nevada. Timber is, fundamentally, a crop. For this reason, Cali- fornia Farm Bureau has maintained a longstanding policy advocating for active forest management and limiting wil- derness areas where management is forbidden. Because timber is a crop, the Forest Service is appro- priately housed as an agency within the U.S. Department of Agriculture. In California, we have 18 national forests covering more than 20 million acres, with nearly 13 million of those acres considered “forested.” Our landscape is a checkerboard of different land man- agement designations across federal and private lands. This maze often creates management decisions that con- flict with one another and makes modern forest resiliency incredibly difficult to achieve. Federal land can be found as national parks, national monuments, national wildlife refuges, Bureau of Rec- lamation lands, Bureau of Land Management lands, military lands, tribal trust lands, designated wilderness areas and federal timberlands. These public woods are supposed to be multiple-use lands serving a variety of interests, including timber, grazing, mining, watershed
VOL. 53, NO. 19
October 7, 2026
AG ALERT ® newspaper is an official publication of the CALIFORNIA FARM BUREAU • CFBF.COM Printed on recycled paper
@cafarmbureau @cafarmbureau @cafarmbureau @cafarmbureau
@cafarmbureau agalert.com
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to AG ALERT, 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento, CA 95833. The California Farm Bureau does not assume responsibility for statements by advertisers or for products advertised in AG ALERT nor does the Federation assume responsibility for statements or expressions of opinion other than in editorials or in articles showing authorship by an officer, director, or employee of the California Farm Bureau Federation or its affiliates. No alcohol, tobacco or political advertising will be accepted. Shannon Douglass, President Shaun Crook, First Vice President Ron Peterson, Second Vice President BOARD OF DIRECTORS: (District 1) Neil Nagata; (2) Richard Schmid; (3) Mark Lopez; (4)
Steven Fenaroli – Managing Director of Public Affairs and Communications
Represented in the East and Midwest by J.L. Farmakis, Inc. Eastern office: Bill Farmakis 24 East Ave, Box 1350, New Canaan, CT 06840, Phone: (203) 834-8832, Fax: (203) 834-8825. Ryder Farmakis 85 John St., Apt 2A, New York, NY 10038, (203) 404-0873. Midwest office: Brenda Murphy W8611 Kent Rd, Poynette, WI 53955, (608) 690-3688. Bob Brunker 8209 NW 81st Ct., Kansas City, MO 64152, (816) 746-8814. Jennifer Saylor 8426 N. Winfield Ave., Kansas City, MO 64153, (816) 912-2804. Laura Rustmann, 901 Lands End Cir, St. Charles MO 63304, (636) 238-8548. AG ALERT (issn 0161-5408) is published biweekly by the California Farm Bureau, 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento CA 95833 (916) 561-5570. Periodicals postage paid at Sacramento, California.
Kevin Merrill; (5) John Moore; (6) Roger Everett; (7) Lorna Roush; (8) April England; (9) Jay Mahil; (10) Jan Garrod; (11) Jeff Dittmer; (12) Steve Kafka; (13) Joey Gonsalves; (14) Joe Fischer; (15) Clark Becker; (16) Garrett Driver; (17) Johnnie White; (18) Daniel Suenram; (19) Taylor Hagata; (20) Martin Spannaus; (21) Ronald Vevoda; (Young Farmers & Ranchers Committee Chair) August D’Amato. ADVISORY MEMBERS: Jenny Holtermann, Chair, CFB Rural Health Department; Glenda Humiston, University of California Cooperative Extension. LETTERS TO THE EDITOR: Send to agalert@cfbf. com or Ag Alert, Attn: Editor, 2600 River Plaza Drive, Sacramento, CA 95833. Include name, address, phone number, email address; 250-word limit.
Ching Lee – Senior Editor Caleb Hampton – Editor Manola Secaira – Staff Writer
Shawn Collins – Production Designer Sam Adams – Multimedia Specialist GENERAL INFORMATION: (916) 561-5570 agalert@cfbf.com ADVERTISING: Mariah Fellows – Sales Manager (916) 561-5575 Antonio Muniz – Sales Coordinator Classifieds: (916) 561-5570, 2600 River Plaza Dr., Sacramento, CA 95833.
If you or someone you know is in crisis, call or text 988 or visit 988lifeline.org
2 Ag Alert October 7, 2026
Powered by FlippingBook